The poll needs a "meh" option. First showing in the theater was great. Lots of similarities to Ep. 4, but that's not really such a terrible thing. But the re-watching value just doesn't seem to be all that high for me. I think in some ways that's due to the amount of time spent introducing the new cast. Meanwhile, I think they missed out for the most part on the opportunity to introduce them through interaction with the old cast. Other than Han/Chewie, there's hardly any. And Han, well...
I'm hopeful for Rogue One and Episode 8. R1 should be an untold story within the existing canon, and Ep 8 should be done with the exposition setting up the new canon and able to get on with actually telling the story. Besides, the second movie's always the best in a trilogy, right?