I think number 1 is going to be the biggest concern when comparing insert, vs stand-alone models. That's all going to come down to the suit fitment.
After that, yes, I think the stand-alone model covering more area is a good thing. Don't just think about your spine and shoulder blades, think about tailbone, kidneys, etc. All things to be concerned with.
I guess I'm more worried about the armor being certified for impact and staying in place than I am about those last X square inches of coverage. If you worry about extra coverage from a stand-alone unit, try wearing your current one for a ride or two (take out that foam) and see if the suit breaks in or not. My guess is it will stretch a little. If not, it might be necessary to find a thinner unit.
|