First and foremost Happy Thanksgiving!
Did what Jac said and started checking voltages. Starter is getting 12v THE ENTIRE TIME the bike is running.
That most certainly explains why the last one crapped out. Trying to check where exactly the issue is coming from (relay, starter switch, etc.) but sadly it's pouring rain here right now.
I will put up some more info as soon as i get it. You have been a great help @
JacRyann. Thank you!