September 17th, 2010, 03:17 PM | #1 |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
The truth about aftermarket air filters
Found this on another site, thought you guys might like to read it, put it here for maximum exposure. Don't believe all the ads and hype and anectdotal comments you read/hear.
http://www.rc51.org/airfilt.htm |
|
September 17th, 2010, 03:19 PM | #2 |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
The truth about aftermarket air filters
Found this on another site, thought you guys might like to read it, put it here for maximum exposure. Don't believe all the ads and hype and anecdotal comments you read/hear.
http://www.rc51.org/airfilt.htm Sorry it came out twice - I can't seem to delete this one. Last futzed with by mrlmd; September 17th, 2010 at 03:25 PM. Reason: trying to delete duplicate post |
|
September 17th, 2010, 03:33 PM | #3 |
Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: Too much.
|
lol... and you feel so strongly about this that you had to post it twice?
|
|
September 17th, 2010, 05:59 PM | #4 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Whodat
Location: Ware Is.,MA
Join Date: Jan 2009 Motorcycle(s): I pass the wind! Posts: A lot.
MOTM - Mar '13, Jun '14
|
Deja Vu
__________________________________________________
If everything seems under control; you're just not going fast enough! |
|
September 17th, 2010, 06:19 PM | #5 |
Small Bike Abuser
Name: Stevo
Location: Seattle Wa
Join Date: Aug 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2010 Ninja 250R SE, GSX650FK8, DL650K5, CH80K2, AN400K7, SH150i Posts: 95
|
Oh, I take it we have been here before then? Better breathing comes at a price.
__________________________________________________
If you are "Too Cool" to be seen on a scooter...you're a Poser |
|
September 17th, 2010, 07:16 PM | #6 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Rick
Location: Alexandria, Louisiana
Join Date: Jan 2009 Motorcycle(s): 05 Blue Ninja 250 Posts: Too much.
MOTY - 2017, MOTM - Jan '19, Oct '16, May '14
|
So good I had to read it both times.
|
|
September 17th, 2010, 08:11 PM | #7 |
Professional belly dancer
Name: James
Location: Toronto
Join Date: Apr 2009 Motorcycle(s): 1992 GSX-R 750 Posts: A lot.
|
Thanks for the link, Marc. I agree with that blurb for the most part. While cars have very restrictive systems sometimes, the intake system on a bike is usually much simpler, and there's usually very little room to improve upon. Obviously this will depend on the actual bike.
I actually only bought a K&N for my bike because spare parts for it are harder to come by with each passing year. Probably should've looked into that before buying it...FML. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 06:26 AM | #8 | |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
Quote:
Or does that belong in the quotes thread? LOL. I couldn't find anyway to delete that second post, and I only hit the button to post it again because the site was so slow at the time, I didn't know if the first one went through 'till it was too late. |
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 07:05 AM | #9 |
ninjette.org guru
Name: Kevin
Location: Athens
Join Date: Aug 2010 Motorcycle(s): 1981 Honda Cx500 Custom, 2002 Ninja 250 Posts: 289
Blog Entries: 1
|
Hmmm I have been thinking about buying a K and N for bike. I have one for my truck and get an extra 2 mpg on average.
__________________________________________________
"Rudeness is a weak persons attempt at strength." |
|
September 18th, 2010, 11:25 AM | #10 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Eric
Location: Iowa City
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Kawmeracchi 350 2010 Project X Posts: A lot.
Blog Entries: 54
MOTM - Sep '18, Feb '16
|
As a mechanic . I always laugh when a car comes in with a K&N filter that is packed with dirt. Life time to some means never touching again.
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 01:25 PM | #11 |
Professional belly dancer
Name: James
Location: Toronto
Join Date: Apr 2009 Motorcycle(s): 1992 GSX-R 750 Posts: A lot.
|
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 02:41 PM | #12 | |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Alex
Location: Belfast, ME
Join Date: Jul 2008 Motorcycle(s): 2010 Honda NT-700-V, formerly, Green 2008 Ninja 250R Posts: A lot.
|
Quote:
|
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 02:50 PM | #13 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Sean
Location: Mary Esther, FL
Join Date: Jan 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 1998 HD Road King Posts: A lot.
|
As far as the 250 goes at least for me, stock air filter FTW.
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 03:20 PM | #14 |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
I think most "modders" somehow think they are smarter than the engineers and designers who build these things, that they know more, that they can improve on something to make more horsepower or whatever they are looking for. For the most part they are wrong. Like high octane gas is better, more power, runs better, has more and better additives, etc, and they are way wrong about that.
If you replace something like an air filter or mod the airbox to improve "flow" (which is adequate already), then you have to rejet and also redo the exhaust, to get any benefit and have the bike not run like crap. You must mod all three to keep it running right. You may spend hundreds of dollars to gain, what, 1 hp, maybe 2? Now granted, most all bikes sold here come lean from the factory for emissions controls and possibly could be tweaked a little, but the overall benefit in terms of dyno measured horsepower is minimal if anything, and fuel economy suffers when these mods are done. I think the engineers did a pretty good job, I think they know what they are doing, and their warranty attests to that and the bikes perform pretty well as is out of the box, until messed with, and then people have all kinds of problems trying to straighten it out and blame it on Kawasaki or whoever made the thing. I am quite satisfied with the performance and reliability of my bikes as is and I think messing with them does just that - messes them up. The retail value of a modded bike is also lower than stock. I am perfectly OK with customizing the appearance or adding things like headlight/brakelight modulators and louder air horns for increased safety, or altering the body work to their own taste, but mechanically I will leave them alone as they work just fine. There are innumerable threads on here and on other forums of individuals who did extensive mods costing hundreds if not thousands of dollars in which the net effect measured objectively was very little. All they accomplished was poorer gas mileage and a great sacrifice of reliability and longevity. But it may have made then feel good so it may have been worth it to them. You want more power -- then get a bigger bike. Just my opinion. I'm sure I'll start some kind of argument on here because I'm sure there are many opinions different than mine. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 03:25 PM | #15 |
Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: Too much.
|
you're entitled to your opinion, even though I don't agree with it.
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 03:57 PM | #16 |
The Sportisi Master
Name: Matt
Location: Chico
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 Posts: A lot.
|
My air filters are free so JFC FTW. Otherwise I would run stock. For those running the KN0990 me and a racer of mine found out that pod filters actually loose hp overall. The gerry rigged intake we came made proved to be best combo. We didn't use the stock runners from the airbox but there is a reason why they are there.
__________________________________________________
Sportisimoto USA is born. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 04:28 PM | #17 |
CVMA #74 WSMC #750
Name: Nemesis
Location: On the track
Join Date: Oct 2009 Motorcycle(s): All of them Posts: A lot.
|
Truth is, you may see an increase on paper but the gains (if any) are so minimal it's hardly noticeable.
With that said, it's just one piece of the puzzle. Buy all the other performance parts, put them together, fine tune it, and you'll see a huge gain. By itself, it's not worth it. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:07 PM | #18 | |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
Quote:
I'm a very pragmatic guy and would like to see some unbiased scientific objective evidence and proof that something works as stated or advertised, no matter what it is, other than hearsay, opinion, hype, advertising, or anecdote. If you want me to switch from doing it my way to yours, then prove to me yours is better. If there's so many more ways to do something, then most of the time it makes little difference which way you do it, that's just personal preference, but the end result is often the same. If one way was proven to be better, then everyone would do it that way and that would be the norm. I find that a lot of what is sold or is done is based on advertising or hype with very little gain except financially for the company promoting it at the expense of the cult or following that falls for it and buys the product. This is not always, not a blanket statement, but is often the case today. Like high octane gas is "better", nitrogen in tires is "better", this air filter or exhaust is "better", etc, up to my God is "better" than yours (from another discussion on here). I have no problem with any mods if anyone can really prove they do something other than make the modder feel happy (which is OK) or that he thinks he accomplished something and his bike is "better". Obviously, sometimes something needs to be fixed, but modding a carb to get the bike to run properly oftentimes is done because it is treating a symptom of poor maintenance, abuse, or another bad mod done to correct a problem which didn't exist in the first place. Can you post another poll about "What is your gas mileage for your stock bike vs. the mileage for your carb/exhaust modded bike? How many bikes on here were tested before and after to see if the 0-60 times actually improved, or the dyno tests demonstrate any real difference in performance? Obviously most everyone on here doesn't do that or could afford it, but all say their bike is "better" but no one can prove it. I'm not down on anyone who wants to play and try and improve their bike's performance, I am just not convinced that any of this really does anything significant. |
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:25 PM | #19 |
Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: Too much.
|
Marc,
If you're happy with the way your bike runs and don't want to experiment, I can live with that. I know what I want out of my bike and try to systematically address what I feel are shortcomings that can be remedied with parts available and still maintain a bike that hopefully is better than what I started with. As long as I'm happy, I really don't care what others think/feel about what I do with my plaything. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:26 PM | #20 |
Small Bike Abuser
Name: Stevo
Location: Seattle Wa
Join Date: Aug 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2010 Ninja 250R SE, GSX650FK8, DL650K5, CH80K2, AN400K7, SH150i Posts: 95
|
In the quest for HP your dollar is better spent on more CC's and not mods on a smaller engine, unless you are competing in a CC class in some sort of sanctioned racing, then yes..throwing money at a certain size engine is a different story.
EDIT: Modding is fun, but you will finally get to point to where you are pissing in the wind as far as your dollar spent and what you will get in return.
__________________________________________________
If you are "Too Cool" to be seen on a scooter...you're a Poser |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:29 PM | #21 |
Humble Observer
Name: Truong
Location: Augusta, Maine
Join Date: Mar 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2009 Yamaha XT250 Posts: 612
|
Aftermarket air filters are a nice alternative if they are replacing a foam OE filter. When the filter needs to be cleaned and reoiled, I like working with a K&N kit (spray bottle of cleaner and aerosol can of oil) than an open basin of cleaner and motor oil as per the owner's manual.
__________________________________________________
Everything I post is "IN MY HONEST OPINION". Why is "Parking Lot Enduro" not a thing? |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:35 PM | #22 |
The Sportisi Master
Name: Matt
Location: Chico
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 Posts: A lot.
|
I have three dynos at my disposal. I have dyno graphs showing gains from a drop in air filter, no filter, pod filter, stock intake runners with unis on the end, and the top secret combo which won't be mentioned. And High Octane is better for my bike and others with similar setups but it is not for those with a completely stock bike.
Your anti mod and I'm fine with that. Whoever posts up immediately after me will receive a FREEEEE drop in air filter that will come in with my next Shipment.
__________________________________________________
Sportisimoto USA is born. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:38 PM | #23 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Cuong
Location: San Diego
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250r, 2007 Daytona 675 Posts: A lot.
|
I win?
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:39 PM | #24 |
The Sportisi Master
Name: Matt
Location: Chico
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 Posts: A lot.
|
Yes sir you do. PM me
__________________________________________________
Sportisimoto USA is born. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:41 PM | #25 | |
Join Date: Nov 2008 Posts: Too much.
|
Quote:
|
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:43 PM | #26 |
The Sportisi Master
Name: Matt
Location: Chico
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 Posts: A lot.
|
let me get the hard copy from Sportisi. I'll call dean in the morning and have him send me his stuff.
__________________________________________________
Sportisimoto USA is born. |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:45 PM | #27 |
Humble Observer
Name: Truong
Location: Augusta, Maine
Join Date: Mar 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2009 Yamaha XT250 Posts: 612
|
Maybe it is sleep deprivation, but an RC51 would be a neato ride even with the least useful air filter setup those guys came up with.
__________________________________________________
Everything I post is "IN MY HONEST OPINION". Why is "Parking Lot Enduro" not a thing? |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:48 PM | #28 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Cuong
Location: San Diego
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250r, 2007 Daytona 675 Posts: A lot.
|
Wow Matt, that's very kind of you. I've actually installed pod filters on my bike though. Maybe you can run a contest for another lucky member here? (or PM me the top secret combo )
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:48 PM | #29 |
I hate driving...
Name: S
Location: SW Ohio
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): 13 Triumph Street Triple R, 09 Ninja 250r (Sold 4/20/12) Posts: A lot.
|
mrlmd you are right In that there is a crap load that engineers go through when designing a bike(fluid mechanics, thermodynamics, knowledge of materials and their corresponding properties, and so forth). Just know that shortcomings will be made when trying to keep a budget on designing and producing a machine. There is also a defined market that the engineers are supposed to design toward. Thus there are reasons why some people mod the bike and some don't. They are made so that they will appease the majority of buyers and you will find a lot of the time you will have something the way you like it.
__________________________________________________
09 ninja 2fiddy SE Driving slow things fast |
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:48 PM | #30 | |
Professional belly dancer
Name: James
Location: Toronto
Join Date: Apr 2009 Motorcycle(s): 1992 GSX-R 750 Posts: A lot.
|
Quote:
But in the grand scheme of things when mods are planned out properly and done well they can be quite effective. Going from a drop in stock filter to a drop in "performance" filter is pretty ludicrous though haha. Going to a pod filter setup and ditching the air box altogether, however, well that's something else entirely. Plus it looks cool. |
|
|
September 18th, 2010, 08:52 PM | #31 |
The Sportisi Master
Name: Matt
Location: Chico
Join Date: May 2009 Motorcycle(s): 2008 Ninja 250 Posts: A lot.
|
secret combo pm'd
__________________________________________________
Sportisimoto USA is born. |
|
September 19th, 2010, 06:31 AM | #32 |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
Are you really getting in any more air than the stock filter provides, any more that the engine can use? If so, then it's running even more lean than stock, so you have to do carb mods to fix it or even make it run well so the mods can function properly. You need to do both, not just change the airbox or filter. And then maybe the exhaust - it's a combo of all three that works the best. That's one point I was also trying to make.
And I know that designing all these bikes is a compromise - between cost, emissions, performance, fuel economy, reliability, longevity, etc, and are not set up perfectly for out and out optimal performance in any of these categories, but like I said, is a compromise between all of them. So you can mod it out anyway you want, to change it, and you will be changing some of the other parameters as well, some for the good, some will be made the worse in the process - it's all a balance. I put that article up there because I think people should get educated and get a little more information about what they are doing or attempting to do, instead of just following the herd. And I need a new filter, I started this this, I need to be converted. I need to mod, I need a filter more than anyone on here. Ha. |
|
September 19th, 2010, 04:17 PM | #33 |
I hate driving...
Name: S
Location: SW Ohio
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): 13 Triumph Street Triple R, 09 Ninja 250r (Sold 4/20/12) Posts: A lot.
|
Good point.
__________________________________________________
09 ninja 2fiddy SE Driving slow things fast |
|
September 19th, 2010, 10:07 PM | #34 |
Eddie
Name: Eduardo
Location: Colton, CA
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): None. Posts: 53
|
i can use a free drop in filter =D
|
|
September 20th, 2010, 06:25 AM | #35 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Spooph
Location: Golden, CO
Join Date: Jul 2010 Motorcycle(s): '08 Ninja 250R Posts: A lot.
MOTM - Oct '15
|
thanks for the article! Even more so because you posted mainly for education! Knowledge is the best way to fight reverse evolution. I've been on the fence about a K&N for a while now, and I think I'll be wasting my money.
In fact, what I got out of this article is that stock air filters breath brilliantly, and that money is best spent elsewhere - exhaust for instance. That's where most of the restriction happens. I'm gonna play around with that this winter....
__________________________________________________
My therapist has 2 wheels and a seat. If you are ever in doubt to my tone, please refer to my avatar. |
|
September 20th, 2010, 08:09 AM | #36 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Jason
Location: Jacksonville, Florida
Join Date: May 2010 Motorcycle(s): 09 Ninja 250R SE, 07 Honda CRF230F, 06 Honda CRF150F Posts: A lot.
|
My 250R is down for now getting the rear wheel mod done. My 250 is modded to the max for performance and using it for reference, it has to be a better performer now. My wife also has a 250. The only mods to it is a jet kit and 15T front sprocket. Well due to mine being in pieces again I choose to ride her in to work this morning. I found myself multiple times wondering where my torque and HP was at. Granted her bike runs as smooth as a sewing machine but it does however lack the performance I have come to expect from my modded 250. I don't have any dyno's to prove torque and HP gains but they ARE there.
I totally agree that if your going to mod one thing, be prepared to change others to get the best each components has to offer. Also understand that there MAY be some loss of that "sewing machine" sound and reliability but I believe it is minimal.
__________________________________________________
09 250R SE: Paying it forward one post at a time! Don't forget to add yourself to our Member Map |
|
September 20th, 2010, 05:39 PM | #37 |
ninjette.org sage
Name: Marc
Location: Crawfordville, Florida
Join Date: Jan 2010 Motorcycle(s): 2005 Suzuki S50, 2006 Kawasaki Ninja EX250F, 1990 Honda PC800, 2000 Yamaha TW200 Posts: 848
|
Don't forget the difference in performance with her 15T sprocket. That alone will make it a lot different than yours with all the "mods" you did. You are not comparing comparable bikes.
And it's not so much that if you mod one thing you have to be prepared to change others to get the best each component has to offer, it's that if you don't, the bike will run like crap or not at all. You can't lean out any more the air/fuel mixture with a less restrictive filter letting in more air without then rejetting the carb to allow more fuel flow. And then you need to have a less restrictive exhaust. The three of those things work together, not one at a time and expecting to accomplish anything except an unbalanced poorly running bike. |
|
September 20th, 2010, 05:59 PM | #38 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Jason
Location: Jacksonville, Florida
Join Date: May 2010 Motorcycle(s): 09 Ninja 250R SE, 07 Honda CRF230F, 06 Honda CRF150F Posts: A lot.
|
I was pretty sure I mentioned that mine had all the performance mods. I can provide a list if needed but I'm pretty sure I ran our of performance mods. In short, if you can think of it, I prolly have it. Btw...mine also has the 15T sprocket.
__________________________________________________
09 250R SE: Paying it forward one post at a time! Don't forget to add yourself to our Member Map |
|
September 23rd, 2010, 06:20 AM | #39 |
ninjette.org certified postwhore
Name: Jason
Location: Jacksonville, Florida
Join Date: May 2010 Motorcycle(s): 09 Ninja 250R SE, 07 Honda CRF230F, 06 Honda CRF150F Posts: A lot.
|
__________________________________________________
09 250R SE: Paying it forward one post at a time! Don't forget to add yourself to our Member Map |
|
September 23rd, 2010, 06:50 AM | #40 |
ninjette.org guru
Name: Remy
Location: Moncton
Join Date: Apr 2009 Motorcycle(s): '04 sv650s Posts: 438
|
This article could be written about complete exhaust system. Air filters and exhaust both need fuel adjustment to maximize their use. That article is very subjective. Air box design have much more effect on the way the engine breath than the filter they use, so a K&N drop in in a bike might gain HP and on another one lose HP.
And don't forget that RC51 and all other fancy 600cc have an intake/air box/fuel tuned for ram air induction..
__________________________________________________
There's 2 types of people in this world, those who complain and those who act. |
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Pipercross air filters. Where??? | evidens83 | General Motorcycling Discussion | 4 | February 9th, 2014 09:12 AM |
Air Filters | 102dalz | 2008 - 2012 Ninja 250R Tech Talk | 2 | September 18th, 2013 06:42 PM |
[sportrider - latest stories] - K&N Air Filters Named as Official Air & Oil Filter Su | Ninjette Newsbot | Motorcycling News | 0 | June 11th, 2012 06:00 PM |
Aftermarket Drop in Type Air Filters | DaBlue1 | 2008 - 2012 Ninja 250R Tech Talk | 11 | April 7th, 2011 05:37 AM |
Air Filters? | mista350z | 2008 - 2012 Ninja 250R Tech Talk | 3 | July 29th, 2009 04:03 PM |
|
|